Questions? Call us:+1 (914) 996-5410
← Back to Blog
Channel StrategyDecember 18, 2025

Amazon vs Walmart: Which Channel Matters More?

If you're an established brand looking to grow your online presence, you've probably wondered: should we focus on Amazon, Walmart, or both? The answer depends on your category, your goals, and your resources — but for most established brands, the answer is both.

Amazon: The Dominant Marketplace

Amazon is the largest e-commerce marketplace in the United States, with over 300 million active customers. For most product categories, Amazon is where the majority of online shopping happens.

**Advantages of Amazon:**

  • Massive customer base and traffic
  • Prime eligibility drives conversion rates
  • Sophisticated advertising platform
  • Robust fulfillment infrastructure (FBA)
  • **Challenges of Amazon:**

  • High fees (typically 15-35% of sale price)
  • Intense competition in most categories
  • Complex algorithm that requires ongoing optimization
  • Strict policies that can lead to account issues
  • Walmart: The Growing Alternative

    Walmart Marketplace has grown significantly in recent years and now represents a major opportunity for established brands. With lower fees and less competition than Amazon, Walmart can be highly profitable for the right brands.

    **Advantages of Walmart:**

  • Lower fees than Amazon (typically 8-15%)
  • Less competition in most categories
  • Growing customer base
  • Strong brand recognition and trust
  • **Challenges of Walmart:**

  • Stricter approval process
  • Less sophisticated advertising platform
  • Smaller customer base than Amazon
  • Different content requirements
  • The Right Strategy: Both Channels

    For most established brands, the best strategy is to be present on both platforms. Here's why:

    1. **Diversification** — relying on a single platform creates risk

    2. **Maximum reach** — different customers shop on different platforms

    3. **Competitive advantage** — many brands only focus on Amazon, leaving Walmart as an opportunity

    The key is to have a strategy tailored to each platform, rather than simply copying your Amazon listings to Walmart.

    What This Means for Your Brand

    Managing two major marketplace channels effectively requires significant expertise and time. That's why many established brands choose to work with a dedicated partner who specializes in both platforms.

    At MontBlack, we manage both Amazon and Walmart for our brand partners — with strategies optimized for each platform's unique requirements and economics.

    Want to discuss your channel strategy?

    Ready to see what this looks like for your brand?

    Book a free 30-minute call. No commitment, no pitch — just an honest conversation.

    Ready to Discuss Your Growth Strategy?

    Let's talk numbers, timelines, and how we can scale your online presence profitably.